true-nature-of-the-collectively-nurtured-vocaloid-characters Vocaloid Character Ontology

Vocaloid Character Ontology

The True Nature of the Feeling That Vocaloid Characters Are Raised by Everyone

The feeling that 'everyone raised the character' refers to the phenomenon where Vocaloid characters such as Hatsune Miku transcend their original design by Crypton Future Media and evolve through countless fan works, songs, illustrations, and videos created by the community as a whole. This intuition frames characters not as owned objects but as entities shared and nurtured collectively. The question asks whether this sensation is mere illusion or an essential process that grants the character its own ontological status. Its scope extends to issues of creative ownership, mechanisms of emotional identification, and the reality of virtual beings.

01 Emergentist View

The view that a character's 'personality' emerges from the sum of individual creations. The community as a whole functions as one vast author, granting the character independent life.

02 Ownership-Centric View

The view that the character's essence lies in official settings and the original author's intent; derivative works are mere extensions. The shared feeling is only an illusion.

03 Relational Character Ontology

The view that a character's existence is continually redefined in each fan's relationship with it. No fixed 'original' exists; it resides solely in the web of relations.

04 Phenomenological View

The view that brackets theoretical ownership and treats the lived experience of 'being raised' itself as the ground of the character's existence. First-person feeling generates reality.

  1. Was there a moment when you felt Hatsune Miku or another Vocaloid character belonged to 'everyone'? Where did that feeling come from?

  2. Have you ever felt that your own derivative work changed how the character is perceived?

  3. Which do you think represents the character's 'true form'—official settings or fan creations?

  4. Was the feeling that a character is 'growing' comforting to you, or did it carry a touch of loneliness?

  5. How did you feel when a favorite character appeared in a completely different form in someone else's work?

  6. If the official side said 'no more derivative works allowed,' do you think the character would die?

Ownership vsSharing
Is a character someone's 'work' or the community's 'common property'? Asserting ownership may restrict creative freedom.
Fixity vsTransformation
Does a character collapse without fixed official settings, or is transformation itself proof of life?
Individual vsCollective
Is the foundation one author's vision or countless anonymous contributions? Which forms the character's 'core'?
Illusion vsReality
Is the feeling of 'raising' mere psychological projection, or does it grant the character new ontological reality?
Talk note

This theme is not about deciding which interpretation is correct. It is a space for putting your own feeling of 'sharing' a character into words and quietly sharing it with others.

Collaborative Creation
The process in which fan secondary creations beyond official settings cumulatively shape a character's image and narrative.
Character Autonomy
The state in which a character appears to possess a 'life' independent of any single creator's intent through community contributions.
Collective Knowledge
The totality of tacit understandings and cultural memories accumulated by the entire fan community.
Derivative Works
Fan-created songs, videos, novels, and other works that build on official settings while adding original interpretations.
Ice breaker

Name one memory of a character you felt was 'raised by everyone.' What did that sensation feel like?

Deep dive

If you were to create a new Vocaloid character from scratch, would you intend from the start that it be 'raised by everyone'?

  • What constitutes the 'death' of a character?
  • Can AI-generated characters also become entities that are 'raised'?
  • What can we learn from historical cases where official sides restricted derivative works?
  • Does conflict of fan interpretations enrich or fracture a character?
  • How does the feeling of 'everyone's' reconcile with commercial use?